Civil liberties in the time of coronavirus

Second Amendment

Civil libertarians say governments have the power to take extraordinary measures to stop the pandemic, but the power is not without limits.

Trump declared on Saturday he was considering quarantines over New York, New Jersey and Connecticut but pulled back after New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and other officials questioned the lawfulness of such a move. Trump opted for a “travel advisory” instead, under which the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have urged people from the three states to refrain from nonessential travel for 14 days.

“(W)e made it clear and he agreed, it would be much better to do what’s called a strong advisory. .. You don’t want to get to the point … that you’re enforcing things that would create a bigger difficulty, morale and otherwise, when you could probably accomplish the same goal.”

Fauci says Trump agreed not to invoke a strict quarantine after intensive White House discussions

What can government do in times like these?

Civil libertarians say steps to prevent the spread of the deadly virus should be weighed in terms of whether effective — and lawful.

“People are afraid. Governments are not entirely sure what to do,” David Cole, national legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union, said Sunday. “The balance between civil liberties and safety changes in the context of a pandemic, but civil liberties and civil rights don’t get thrown out the window.”


Governments have struggled through the ages to deal with emergencies, whether they be an earthquake, hurricane or pestilence, said Ilya Shapiro, director of the Cato Institute’s Center for Constitutional Studies.

“You have to tailor your emergency measures to the nature of the emergency. In a hurricane, you evacuate the coasts. In a virus situation, there is no reason to evacuate the coasts,” said Shapiro, adding that his overriding concern is whether the “cures” become worse than the disease and whether some measures become long-term, such as any new government surveillance and tracking.

Legal experts say that broad measures that are reasonable and apply to everyone, for example “shelter in place” requirements, are generally lawful. But if government begins to target certain individuals or businesses, there should be ways to ensure a hearing and due process of law. Quarantines have been imposed over the centuries, but longstanding case law dictates that they not be unreasonable or arbitrary.

With the country just weeks into the current pandemic and a barrage of shutdown orders and travel restrictions, it is difficult to predict the depth of this new chapter of tensions regarding civil liberties.

NRA sues California Gov. Gavin Newsom and other state officials over gun store closures

Certainly, the country has faced natural disasters and a multitude of regional health emergencies in the past century. But none would compare to this national pandemic.

Its toll is fast-moving and so are the responses of government officials.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, who had already instituted a 14-day self-quarantine for anyone traveling to Texas from New York, New Jersey, Connecticut and the city of New Orleans, on Sunday afternoon said that anybody driving into Texas from Louisiana, as well as anybody traveling from various places around the country, would have to self-quarantine for 14 days.

“Presuming that a random driver from Louisiana poses a greater risk of contagion than a random Texan is wholly arbitrary,” said Cole of the ACLU. “We are one country, and should be fighting this together.”

Abbott said he would be dispatching state troopers at and near entry points from Louisiana to enforce the order.

Meanwhile, lawsuits already have been filed over whether abortion clinics or gun stores, for example, can be regarded as nonessential services. And detainees in immigration and pretrial detention who might be especially vulnerable to contagion have been challenging their confinement.
Voters and their advocates in many states are trying to ensure that electoral systems are updated, for example, with greater mail-in options, to ensure ballots can be cast and counted in upcoming presidential primaries and the general election. And concerns are emerging about discrimination and rationing as hospitals become overwhelmed with the sick.

Deciding what’s essential during a situation

Since the early 1800s, federal and state courts have granted governments broad latitude to impose quarantines for public health. The Congressional Research Service has documented quarantine laws over the years, noting that states typically focused on specific disease outbreaks such as typhoid fever and tuberculosis. CRS noted that no large-scale US quarantine has been in place since the 1918 influenza pandemic.

In a March 17 report, updated after recent travel restrictions related to coronavirus were enacted, CRS asserted that “courts have recognized that expeditious actions by government officials are frequently required to protect public health or safety,” and it observed that judges are apt to let government act fast to head off health risks.

Beyond travel restrictions, government actions are beginning to be tested. Federal judges in recent days ordered the release of certain immigrants at high-risk of illness held in detention facilities.
Federal judge orders release of some immigrants in detention due to coronavirus outbreak, blasts ICE
Abortion-rights advocates have sued state officials that have tried to shut down clinics, as in Ohio and Texas, categorizing them as nonessential services in coronavirus orders. Gun rights activists have similarly challenged state laws that would close firearms stores. The National Rifle Association on Friday sued California over such a policy.

Shapiro of the Cato Institute, who is a longtime supporter of broad Second Amendment rights, said Sunday that “a right of self-defense is paramount in these times” and if states close gun stores, they could “inflame a panic.”

When Cuomo pushed back on Trump’s proposal for a three-state quarantine, the Democratic governor predicted it could cause “mayhem” and questioned how officials could even enforce such a lockdown.

Enforcement is an overriding dilemma for any restrictions as officials simultaneously try to ease jail and prison crowding.

Said the ACLU’s Cole: “The last thing anyone wants to do now is put more people in detention, where there is tremendous risk of coronavirus infection and spread.”

Source link

Articles You May Like

Letter: I’m worried about gun violence for good reason – InForum
Rep. Dennis Miller says property taxes ‘most pressing concern’
Opinion | Kansas City shooting: Again. Guns again.
Reader Opinion: Turning a deaf ear – Brainerd Dispatch
All Ball Sports: Kansas City Blues, Sea Hawks bright


  1. 561798 219727Someone essentially assist to make severely posts I may state. That may be the very 1st time I frequented your site page and so far? I surprised with the analysis you made to create this particular submit incredible. Magnificent task! 437992

  2. 540866 446274Aw, this was a truly good post. In concept I wish to put in writing like this furthermore ?taking time and actual effort to make an excellent article?nonetheless what can I say?I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get something done. 619468

  3. 27802 788358An attention-grabbing dialogue is value comment. Im confident that its better to write on this subject, towards the often be a taboo subject but typically persons are not sufficient to speak on such topics. To another location. Cheers 33627

  4. 52 591659Spot on with this write-up, I truly suppose this web site needs a lot a lot more consideration. probably be once far more to learn way far more, thanks for that info. 498591

  5. 298686 996394The subsequent time I read a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a great deal as this one. I mean, I know it was my option to read, but I truly thought youd have something attention-grabbing to say. All I hear is actually a bunch of whining about something that you possibly can repair should you werent too busy on the lookout for attention. 196182

  6. 121643 147730Dude.. My group is not considerably into looking at, but somehow I acquired to read several articles on your blog. Its wonderful how interesting it is for me to visit you fairly often. 162985

  7. 818800 471279There a couple of interesting points more than time here but I dont know if I see them all center to heart. There exists some validity but Let me take hold opinion until I look into it further. Very good post , thanks and now we want more! Included with FeedBurner at exactly the same time 721994

  8. 988657 660943Hmm is anyone else encountering difficulties with the pictures on this blog loading? Im trying to figure out if its a dilemma on my end or if its the blog. Any responses would be greatly appreciated. 569495

  9. 837663 9582I discovered your blog web site on google and check a couple of of your early posts. Proceed to maintain up the excellent operate. I just extra up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. In search of ahead to studying extra from you in a although! 800209

  10. 427147 473368In fact your creative writing skills has inspired me to get my own website now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings fast. Your write up is a good example of it. 461686

  11. Semrush Group Buy has been an amazing boost to my digital marketing efforts!

    Access to a group of premium SEO tools at such low cost is a marketing dream
    come true. It’s improved my strategy by helping me
    analyze and improve in a precise manner.
    Highly recommended for anyone who is serious in improving their online presence without breaking the budget!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *