For observers familiar with Canada’s long–gun registry, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s scheme to implement his “assault weapons” ban is already giving off a whiff of déjà vu.
Under the Trudeau government’s ban and confiscation program announced on May 1, over 1,500 firearms and devices listed in a government regulation immediately became a “prohibited” firearm or “prohibited device,” as did “any variants or modified versions.”
The law includes a two-year “amnesty” period ending April 30, 2022. A “regulatory impact analysis statement” released with the gun ban regulation states: “During the amnesty period, the Government intends to implement a buy-back program to compensate affected owners for the value of their firearms after they are delivered to a police officer; however, until a buy-back program is offered, affected owners will not be eligible for compensation. An option to participate in a grandfathering regime would also be made available for affected owners. Further public communications on the buy-back program and the grandfathering regime will follow later.” In the meantime, use of the banned firearm or device is almost completely prohibited.
The problems began almost immediately. The law had a much broader reach than advertised, as it became known that the RCMP was adding, as “prohibited,” over a thousand firearms that weren’t directly mentioned in the May regulation. Gun rights groups also questioned the validity of standards in the regulation based on a firearm’s bore diameter or the muzzle energy in discharging a projectile.
It is now apparent that the government had no implementation plan in place at the time the May gun ban took effect, as it wasn’t until August that private contractors were reportedly contacted for expressions of interest in administering the so-called “buyback” (Notice of Proposed Procurement” on “Compensation Model and Program Design Options for a Potential Buyback Program for Recently Prohibited Firearms,” No. 202101502). The Notice had an initial “Phase One” deadline of March 31, 2021 – almost a year into the amnesty period. Phase One covers the theoretical program design and the development of “compensation model options,” but “does not include initiating the delivery of the buy-back program.”
As of late September, no contractor has been announced and the details of the confiscation program and “grandfathering” option remain a complete blank.
A news source quotes a spokesperson’s evasive hedging on the timing and whether the program will even be operational by the time the amnesty expires: “While it is the government’s intent to bring a buy-back program forward during the amnesty period, it is too early to devise with a degree of precision the exact timelines against which such a program would run.”
Another huge question mark is the economic fallout of the gun ban. One initial estimate of the “buyback” program cost topped out at a maximum of CDN$600 million. The “regulatory impact analysis statement” is less forthcoming, stating only that “the costs associated with implementing a buy-back program and grandfathering regime have not yet been finalized.” It adds that the ban will have additional unknown costs due to the economic impact on small businesses, manufacturers, sport shooting, and hunting (hunting alone “contributes an estimated $4.1 billion to Canada’s GDP as well as $2 billion in labour income, and supports about 33,313 full-time equivalent jobs”).
Canadians have already paid heavily for one failed Liberal experiment in gun control. The notorious national gun registry that took effect in 1998 was promised to cost taxpayers no more than CDN$2 million. In 2002, the federal Auditor General’s report predicted that by 2005, the costs to the Department of Justice alone would be 500 times that amount, over $1 billion. Besides the stupendous cost overruns, her report identified additional, serious concerns with the gun registry.
First and foremost, the federal Department of Justice did not “provide Parliament with sufficient information to allow it to effectively scrutinize” the program and ensure accountability, and provided insufficient information to explain “the dramatic increase” in the program costs. Funding assumptions were “unrealistic,” and the financial information disclosed did not fairly represent the government’s program costs. The costs to comply incurred by provinces, territories, firearm owners, firearm clubs, manufacturers, sellers, importers and exporters of firearms were not reported and not included. Significantly, the program had become “excessively regulatory.” This “excessive focus on regulation and control” was explained by the fact that some “Program partners believed that the use of firearms is in itself a ‘questionable activity’ that required strong controls, and that there should be a zero-tolerance attitude towards non-compliance…”
In the end, the registry – with no discernible public benefit – cost Canada’s taxpayers at least $2.7 billion before it was discontinued by Stephen Harper’s Conservative government in 2012.
Asked about the registry in 2012, Justin Trudeau could do no less than call it a “failure.”
With a ballooning federal deficit and an economy struggling to cope with the COVID pandemic, anxious Canadians are right to be concerned about the Liberals’ track record and the lengths to which they will go to turn Canada into their version of a gun control utopia.
414679 76097When I initially commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a remark is added I get four emails with exactly the same comment. Is there any manner you possibly can take away me from that service? Thanks! 398412
258075 541744Directories such given that the Yellow Websites require not list them, so unlisted numbers strength sometimes be alive more harm than financial assistance. 415904
179179 506117A great clear cut answer and a great concept. But how do I post any work on this website is an additional question. The Foureyed Poet. 46072
890002 120806extremely good post, i actually love this internet internet site, maintain on it 707688
363615 571731Hi there! Do you use Twitter? Id like to follow you if that would be ok. Im undoubtedly enjoying your weblog and look forward to new posts. 303336
895443 224938Interested in start up a online business on line denotes revealing your service also providers not only to humans within your town, nevertheless , to numerous future prospects which are cyberspace on numerous occasions. pays every day 46175
136878 69919But wanna remark that you have a really decent internet internet site , I love the design it actually stands out. 572498
801236 626915Im not certain exactly why but this internet internet site is loading extremely slow for me. Is anyone else having this problem or is it a dilemma on my finish? Ill check back later and see if the dilemma still exists. 797176
408797 78655One can undertake all sorts of advised excursions with assorted limousine functions. Various offer great courses and a lot of can take clients for just about any ride your bike more than the investment banking region, or even for a vacation to new york. ??????? 797760
221189 449008Normally I do not read post on blogs, nonetheless I wish to say that this write-up extremely forced me to look at and do so! Your writing taste has been amazed me. Thanks, very wonderful post. 372307
378254 545525It is essential to have having access to the understanding posted here 130822
273440 277116I see something genuinely interesting about your internet web site so I saved to bookmarks . 463635
906940 964383I dont normally look at these types of internet sites (Im a pretty modest person) – but even though I was a bit shocked as I was reading, I was surely a bit excited as properly. Thanks for producing my day 566438
Ahrefs Group Buy has changed the game for my SEO game! Access to high-quality tools at
a reasonable cost has boosted my strategy. The collaboration model
makes it affordable for everyone. Highly recommended for anyone serious about transforming
their lives digitally!
793989 985037This constantly amazes me exactly how blog owners for example yourself can find the time and also the commitment to maintain on composing great blog posts. Your site isexcellent and one of my own ought to read blogs. I just want to thank you. 897226
733995 815607I like this internet website quite significantly, Its a genuinely nice post to read and get info . 11888
430871 689703I feel you did an awesome job explaining it. Certain beats having to research it on my own. Thanks 801823
1491 546443Greetings! Quick question thats completely off subject. Do you know how to make your web site mobile friendly? My internet site looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone. Im trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to correct this concern. In case you have any suggestions, please share. With thanks! 86718
787277 546123hi good page i will definaely come back and see again. 499645