Judge appears ready to shoot down NRA’s countersuit against NY AG Letitia James

Gun News


A Manhattan judge indicated Friday that he doesn’t believe New York’s attorney general has been illegally gunning for the National Rifle Association.

AG Letitia James filed suit against the gun rights group in 2020, claiming its top executives flouted nonprofit laws by diverting millions of agency dollars to fund their lavish lifestyles replete with trips to the Bahamas, safaris in Africa and jaunts on yachts.

The NRA filed counterclaims alleging that even while James was on the campaign trail, she made comments about going after the group, showing that she had “predetermined” to sue it simply because she disagreed with its political stances.

During a video hearing Friday, Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Joel Cohen said, “The attorney general’s job is to decide what cases to bring and try to persuade a jury or a court.”

He added to the NRA’s lawyers, “The claims you’re bringing here really do ask me to cross over and meddle with and look into the mind of law enforcement.”

The judge said he can’t “undo [James’] prosecutorial decisions” and noted that it’s normal for those in public office to lay out their agendas when they run.

bahamas
New York Attorney General Letitia James filed a suit against the NRA, alleging it broke nonprofit laws to fund lavish trips.
Getty Images

Earlier in the hearing, NRA lawyer Svetlana Eisenberg had argued, “If [James] went after the NRA because she disagrees with its political speech and that was a substantial motivator for what she did — that is a First Amendment violation.”

But Monica Connell, a lawyer with the AG’s office, argued that the attorney general has immunity from these claims as a prosecutor.

“The attorney general is authorized to regulate charities, she is authorized to prosecute civil violations of not-for-profit law,” Connell said.

Cohen said he would rule on the issue at a later date.



Source link

Articles You May Like

ILA | NRA-ILA Backed Lawsuit Filed to Challenging Oregon Measure 114
ILA | Did Biden Call Most American Gun Owners Sick?
What is the status of Oregon Measure 114 new gun limits?
Oregon Measure 114 draws third legal suit, latest from NRA, National Shooting Sports Foundation
Distracted driving; blood on their hands; fossil fuel protests; old format option

10 Comments

  1. 513156 707444Its perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be pleased. Ive read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this post. I want to read even more items about it! 964936

  2. 666135 548248Aw, it was a really great post. In concept I ought to put in writing comparable to this in addition – spending time and actual effort to manufacture a superb article but exactly what do I say I procrastinate alot and no indicates discover a way to go carried out. 134151

  3. 255351 27543The Case For HIIT Cardio – Why You need to Concider it By the way you may want to take a look at this cool web site I found 197864

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *