JOHN BRUMMETT: Drawing the line(s)

Gun News

A group filed Friday a proposed state constitutional amendment to take post-census redistricting from politicians and give it to independent citizens.

The development advances a trend in Arkansas by which people work directly to get big things done politically because the politicians resist doing those big things.

That sounds ironic–this idea that politicians fear the will of the people–but it’s logical.

Politicians fret they might lose their offices–oh, dear, not that–because the subsets of people who compose their political “bases” don’t approve of things the people overall desire.

A small subset of people can beat in a party primary an officeholder committing a perceived slight within that subset; but, in a heavy general election turnout, the people overall might overwhelmingly approve of that action for which the subset punishes the offending politician.

Take gun laws, for example. Republican officeholders dare not offend the National Rifle Association lest they lose in a party primary controlled by a small subset. But common-sense gun reforms like universal background checks are favored overall by the people in poll after poll.

In our raging illness called politics as usual, subsets hold more power than the whole. The state motto might better be whatever the Latin phrase is for “subsets rule.”

What we see happening as a result in recent years in Arkansas is this new dynamic: If you want something big done, then you blow through the controlling subsets to get your proposal on a general election ballot offering the greater chance of success offered by the will of the people overall.

That’s how we got the minimum wage raised. It’s how we got medical marijuana passed.

Now there is this new issue: David Couch, the Little Rock lawyer integral to those just-mentioned citizens’ petition efforts, helped file Friday with the secretary of state this proposed constitutional amendment to transfer the responsibility and authority on state legislative and congressional redistricting to the independent citizens commission.

On this issue, Couch works with a newly formed group calling itself “Arkansas Voters First” and led in part by members of the nonpartisan, good-government League of Women Voters.

The subset-versus-whole conflict here is fully clear: Elected politicians are danged well not going to give up the power to draw their own districts and perpetuate themselves. The controlling political party can’t be expected to advance general interest, but to preserve partisan interest, in that decennial process. That’s how we get gerrymandering.

So we will now proceed on that issue directly to all the people with a proposed ballot issue for November titled “The Arkansas Citizens’ Redistricting Commission Amendment.”

You might be running into petition canvassers this week. The old procedural step of editing these citizens’ proposals in the attorney general’s office has been eliminated, at the attorney general’s request. Now, canvassing for petition signatures may proceed immediately pending certification by the State Board of Election Commissioners, whose decision to certify or deny can be appealed directly to the Arkansas Supreme Court.

Offhand I’m not seeing anything misleading in this proposal’s blandly accurate aforementioned title, nor in the text outlining the new process to be followed to reapportion state legislative districts and redistrict congressional districts in 2021 and every decade thereafter.

Currently under the state Constitution, the 135 state legislative districts are drawn by a board composed of the governor, attorney general and secretary of state. The congressional districts are drawn by the Legislature, mainly through the joint work of the House and Senate State Agencies and Governmental Affairs Committees.

The replacement process laid out in the proposed amendment endures a bit of probably necessary convolution toward what ultimately is a very simple system.

Persons wanting to be independent redistricting commissioners would so apply, as long as they weren’t elected officials or lobbyists or relatives thereto. The chief justice of the Arkansas Supreme Court would appoint a panel of three retired judges to screen applicants and recommend best prospects. The governor and the four partisan leaders of the House and Senate would get to make two strikes each among those recommended. Then nine commissioners would be drawn, and drawings would be repeated until all congressional districts were represented.

Then the nine-member commission would put together the staff compiling the data and drawing the maps to get districts adapted to new population figures in ways that would be equal or nearly so and contiguous.

You will hear Republicans gripe about this proposal for this reason: Democrats ran redistricting for decades, but only now, when Republicans take charge, do people come forward trying to make the process independent.

I invite you to consider whether that’s more a substantive and principled point or a whine.

I also invite you to consider whether it’s ever the wrong time for better government.


John Brummett, whose column appears regularly in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, is a member of the Arkansas Writers’ Hall of Fame. Email him at Read his @johnbrummett Twitter feed.

Editorial on 03/08/2020

Source link

Articles You May Like

Letter To The Editor: About Restricting Guns…
JOSH HAMMER: “Hunter Biden’s Firearm Charge Poses Significant Concerns for the Biden Crime Family”
Louisiana Will Adopt Constitutional Carry When I’m Governor
The high price of Alabama’s low taxes
Will TED NUGENT Finally Get Inducted Into ROCK HALL Following JANN WENNER’s Ouster?


  1. 146475 575493Likely to commence a business venture about the refers to disclosing your products and so programs not just to individuals near you, remember, though , to several potential prospects more via the www often. earn funds 511613

  2. гостевой дом дельта ялта свердлова
    ай тодор крым гостиницы ломоносова санаторий нижние серги официальный сайт
    гостиница оазис югорск гостиница беларусь сочи отели в лодейном поле

  3. санаторий пятигорский нарзан в пятигорске отель люко санкт петербург
    пансионаты евпатории с бассейном сибирская 15 сургут в городе сочи белые ночи
    лазаревское отдых у моря с бассейном фаринготрахеит симптомы аркале

  4. набережные челны ижминводы расписание автобусов отель беккер в янтарном
    газета горячий ключ официальный сайт зеленый мыс цены архыз отели с бассейном теплым на улице
    жемчужина сочи отзывы 2016 гостиница вита анапа жемчужина кавказа цены

  5. кучугуры санаторий искра официальный сайт пансионат лазурь
    витязево отель корона цены деметра витязево официальный сайт спа отель весна сочи
    канатка кисловодск цена санаторий россия адрес гостиница карелия санкт петербург

  6. казань санатории и дома отдыха пансионат в новом свете крым
    барнаульский санаторий светлана в сочи гостиница времена года москва
    ласточка крым гостиница дом артиста нижний новгород холидей инн экспресс спб

  7. сколько санаториев в пятигорске гостиница исеть екатеринбург адрес
    гостиница олимпийская сочи санаторий железноводска явпитере апарт отель санкт петербург
    гостиница батайск парк отель манжерок горный алтай официальный сайт кострома отели с бассейном

  8. курорты на алтае камарит 2
    санатории судака крым отель хостел питер отель рица абхазия
    крым отель море спа резорт отдых подмосковье бассейн шведский стол лечебные санатории в ленинградской области

  9. санатории с бассейном недорого гостиница гранд отель кисловодск
    абхазия отдых 2021 пансионаты отель эмеральд екатеринбург официальный волжский утес санаторий официальный сайт цены
    рейтинг отелей сочи с бассейном заполярье сочи адрес отель ямал небуг официальный сайт

  10. орбиталь отель санкт петербург ирей семидворье официальный сайт
    ялта военный санаторий мо рф официальный сайт alean геленджик санаторий зеленоградск калининградская область
    отели туапсе на берегу моря с бассейном гостиница новотель москва шереметьево база отдыха все включено тверская область

  11. мини отель серебряный век санкт петербург отзывы о гостинице тулица тула
    расписание электричек туапсе головинка гостиница россия новомосковск анапа золотая лагуна
    самый близкий курорт от краснодара отдых в горячем ключе на выходные недорого гостиничный комплекс ялта интурист

  12. санаторий вулан официальный сайт стоимость проживания в крыму
    центр курортная деревня хостел дом путешественника ярославль гостиница омега сириус сочи
    гостиницы шатура гагры отели цены 2021 бридж резорт адрес

  13. я туроператор анапа бетта
    гринцовский пансионат ялта дубрава смоленск гостиница гринн орел официальный сайт цены
    отдых в анапе 2017 все включено путевка в санаторий гостиница в татарске новосибирской области

  14. санаторно курортное лечение в подмосковье ооо отдых
    санатории челябинская область официальный сайт что такое кмв санатории кисловодска целебный нарзан
    сертификат на путевку вулан архипо осиповка официальный лоо горный воздух

  15. феодосия хостел отели побережья краснодарского края
    времена года сочи отель прага камышин мини отель вариант
    санаторий машук пятигорск адрес санатории для аллергиков детей побережье анапы курорты

  16. 41918 52477Hiya! Amazing weblog! I happen to be a day-to-day visitor to your website (somewhat more like addict ) of this website. Just wanted to say I appreciate your blogs and am searching forward for a lot more! 408795

  17. 739249 689810Hmm is anyone else encountering troubles with the pictures on this weblog loading? Im trying to figure out if its a dilemma on my end or if it is the weblog. Any responses would be greatly appreciated. 89609

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *