Supreme Court makes no 2nd Amendment ruling in New York gun case

Second Amendment


A 2nd Amendment challenge to a New York City gun ordinance fizzled in the Supreme Court on Monday, but conservative justices looked poised to expand gun rights in future cases.

In a brief unsigned opinion, the high court said the New York case was moot because the city had repealed an ordinance that barred licensed gun owners from carrying their weapons across town or outside the city. Their permits allowed them to have a gun at home, but not to travel with it.

It’s only the latest disappointment for 2nd Amendment advocates. For a decade, they have tried and failed to get the Supreme Court to rule squarely on whether gun owners have a constitutional right to carry a firearm with them in public.

Monday’s decision revealed that at least four justices are ready to rule for expanded gun rights. Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil M. Gorsuch joined a 31-page dissent written by Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. “This is not moot. The city violated petitioners’ 2nd Amendment right, and we should so hold,” Alito wrote in New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn. vs City of New York.

Kavanaugh wrote a short concurring opinion to say that while he agreed with the majority that the case was moot, he also agreed with the conservatives on the need to clarify and expand gun rights.

“I share Justice Alito’s concern that some federal and state courts may not be properly applying Heller and McDonald,” he said, referring to the rulings in 2008 and 2010 that struck down city bans on private hand guns in Washington D. C. and Chicago. “The court should address that issue soon, perhaps in one of the several 2nd Amendment cases with petitions for certiorari now pending before the court,” he said. As an appeals court judge, Kavanaugh wrote a dissent arguing that Washington’s ban on semi-automatic rifles violated the 2nd Amendment.

That leaves Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. holding the deciding vote in future gun cases. He joined the 5-4 rulings that held residents had a right to have a gun at home for self-defense. But since then, the court has repeatedly refused to go further and rule on whether the 2nd Amendment protects a right to carry a gun in public or to own a semiautomatic weapon.

The chief justice is inclined to avoid rulings on major issues if the court is not required to intervene, and he apparently saw no need to decide a far-reaching constitutional question challenging an ordinance that been repealed.

New York, California and other liberal states continue to enforce restrictions on who can carry guns in public and under what circumstances. And the justices have repeatedly refused to strike down those laws.

Gun control advocates were relieved by the outcome.

Hannah Shearer, litigation director for the Giffords Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence, said the decision to “dismiss the case as moot is a victory for the rule of law and common-sense, constitutional gun safety laws. [It] rejects the NRA’s invitation to use a moot case to enact its extreme agenda aimed at gutting gun safety laws supported by a majority of Americans.”

Ilya Shapiro, a lawyer for the libertarian Cato Institute, faulted the court for not issuing a decision. “I agree with the dissenters’ lament that the city of New York has effectively hoodwinked the Supreme Court. After the Court abdicated its duty to explain the scope of the 2nd Amendment for over a decade — allowing judicial resistance to the enforcement of 2nd Amendment rights to build — it has now told states and cities that opportunistic lawyering can allow that constitutional disobedience to continue,” he said. “And we see yet again that Justice Kavanaugh, while probably solid on the merits, is quite cagey on procedural and docket questions, going along with chief justice’s project to kick as many cans down the road as possible.”

The justices sent the New York case back to lower courts to decide whether the gun owners who brought suit may seek damages for the time when they were denied the right to travel with their firearms.



Source link

Articles You May Like

‘Protect kids, not guns’: Doctors urge lawmakers to pass assault weapons ban
ILA | New Jersey: Bruen End Run Legislation Nearing the Finish Line
Number One Responsibility for All 46 Presidents Is Contained in the Oath of Office: Protect the Constitution
Del. Brewer proposes allowing concealed carry in Capitol Square – Smithfield Times
ILA | On Crime, We Know What Works

19 Comments

  1. 400865 364721I enjoyed reading your pleasant site. I see you offer priceless info. stumbled into this website by chance but Im confident glad I clicked on that link. You undoubtedly answered all of the questions Ive been dying to answer for some time now. Will certainly come back for a lot more of this. 996898

  2. 435218 1584Wow that was strange. I just wrote an incredibly long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didnt appear. Grrrr effectively Im not writing all that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say amazing weblog! 201684

  3. подснежник турбаза тольятти пансионат водопад абхазия новый афон отзывы
    железноводск санаторий салют фото кристалл парк таганрог бизнес центр волга плаза липецк
    отель каретный двор цветной бульвар рига отель крым увильды цены на 2021 год

  4. махачкала отдых с детьми гостиница космос адрес москва
    курорты абхазии отзывы гостиница карс козельск дружба московская область
    отель аква вита отель с парковкой в санкт петербурге недорого талион отель спб

  5. санаторий сосновая роща кисловодск официальный сайт турбаза золотой пляж
    туры в кисловодск из москвы снять жилье в алуште возле моря отель радуга феодосия
    отдых в ленобласти с питанием парк отель в суздале все включено база отдыха взлет геленджик

  6. отдых в мысовом сочи санаторий сочинский
    сан марино отзывы здравница евпатория garden resort gagra 4 абхазия гагра
    green park ялта спа звездный сочи гостевой дом терем углич официальный сайт

  7. отель ливадия ялта евпатория санаторий здравница официальный сайт
    ток горизонт судак официальный сайт анапа отель белый песок крым отель море
    отель в гагре бридж фэмили резорт 3 адлер санаторий нехама отзывы

  8. какие ессентуки для желудка гостиница русская охота самара
    вертикаль гостиница санкт петербург официальный сайт дешевая гостиница в ханты мансийске температура моря в хосте
    отели астрахани на берегу волги лучшие спа отели в спб где отдохнуть в дивноморске

  9. яхт клуб 40 меридиан коломна светлогорск санаторий янтарь официальный сайт
    корона алтая база отдыха официальный сайт red room спб сауна лазаревское
    санаторий бургас сочи yalta intourist санаторий знание сочи адрес

  10. отель планета дивеево забронировать отель в сочи с бассейном
    санаторий фсб в евпатории официальный сайт отель демократ на каменноостровском 26 28 санаторий космос елабуга официальный сайт
    база отдыха сказка краснодар хутор ленина дружба адрес термальные источники карелии

  11. ривьера резорт евпатория пансионат колхида пицунда
    золотой берег крым официальный сайт mirage hotel казань казань мано отель
    парк отель немчиновка бонжур сукко гостиница де арт 13

  12. санаторно курортная карта срок действия по закону napa hotel spa отель абхазия цандрипш
    бассейн с морской водой ялта санаторий ставрополь тольятти цены на 2021 год санрайз анапа официальный сайт
    кировск гостиницы санаторий сибирь телефон отель астон санкт петербург официальный сайт

  13. санаторий малая бухта анапа официальный отели иркутск
    теплые бассейны в адлере евпатория туры отель моцарт динская
    ходьба босиком порто маре алушта цены 2021 отель версаль домбай

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *