On July 14, a judge in Lynchburg, VA, partially blocked enforcement of the Commonwealth’s new ban on private firearm sales, ruling it effectively prohibits law-abiding adults under age 21 from acquiring handguns, in violation of Virginia’s constitutional right to keep and bear arms. The decision came in the case of Elhert v. Settle.
“Prior to the [challenged] Act,” the court wrote, “those between the ages of 18 and 21 could purchase a handgun through only a private sale, not from a licensed dealer.” This is because licensed dealers (FFLs) are bound by a federal law that prohibits FFLs from transferring handguns to those under age 21. By channeling all firearms sales through FFLs, Virginia’s new law categorically bans adults age 18 to 20 from legally acquiring handguns.
While attorneys for the Commonwealth admitted this was the outcome of the law, they insisted it didn’t matter, because young adults are not protected by the right to keep and bear arms. The court rejected this claim, noting that the only aged-based restrictions with any longstanding historical pedigree are those pertaining to minors. Meanwhile, the court noted, Virginia law “defines an adult as a person 18 years of age or more.”
The court also determined that completely prohibiting access to an entire class of firearms “is a prohibition, not a mere condition [of sales], infringing on the right to keep and bear arms and greatly reducing [the plaintiff’s] means of self-defense. “ It further noted that it was no answer to this infringement that other types of firearms remain available to this age group, pointing out that the U.S. Supreme Court had foreclosed this argument in the 2008 case of District of Columbia v. Heller.
The court, however, declined the plaintiffs’ request to block the entire law from implementation. In doing so, it determined that Virginia’s constitutional right to arms is equivalent to the Second Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, infringements of which are to be judged by considering the history and tradition of that provision.
Purporting to apply this test, the court pointed out that the U.S. Supreme Court has noted that “prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill” and “conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms” are “presumptively lawful.” From this, the Virginia court extrapolated that a background check requirement for sales does not transgress the right, so long as it “is limited to preventing a longstanding prohibition on a historically justified category.”
The court brushed aside the plaintiffs’ argument that the new law specifically targets private sales, not commercial transactions. “Even though private sales and commercial sales are different,” it stated, “the Court is at a loss as to how the historical justifications of preventing felons and the mentally disabled from possessing firearms would allow conditions on commercial sales and not also justify conditions on private sales.”
While the court’s decision provides some encouragement to Virginians now subject to a jumble of newly-enacted gun control laws, it remains to be seen whether even this incremental relief will survive further proceedings in Virginia’s appellate courts. We will report on any further developments as they occur.
996261 238238You genuinely really should experience a tournament for starters with the finest blogs online. Let me recommend this great site! 939670
400511 829051Quite interesting topic , regards for putting up. 360460
941306 413992very nice publish, i undoubtedly enjoy this internet website, carry on it 18837
784529 706240The Twitter application page will open. This is great if youve got a couple of thousand followers, but as you get a lot more and far more the usefulness of this tool is downgraded. 161719
149726 508762I believe this web website has got extremely great indited written content material articles . 591915
865026 153198Whoah this weblog is magnificent i really like reading your articles. Keep up the good paintings! You realize, lots of persons are looking round for this information, you could aid them greatly. 305218
997319 475538This design is spectacular! You obviously know how to maintain a reader amused. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own weblog (effectively, almostHaHa!) Amazing job. I genuinely enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it. Too cool! 30977
432795 350929Some truly marvelous function on behalf of the owner of this internet website , dead wonderful articles . 572608
787011 941741Glad to be 1 of many visitants on this remarkable internet internet site : D. 703151
968995 111358I like this web internet site its a master peace ! Glad I detected this on google . 796208
203901 159277you can have an ideal weblog correct here! would you prefer to make some invite posts on my weblog? 772891
120631 866815I enjoy your composing design, do carry on creating! I is going to be back! 415556