The Ninth Circuit’s Gun Decision Says Much About the Court

Second Amendment

On Friday, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals handed down a decision of immense importance. In Duncan v. Becerra, the Court struck down California’s ban on firearm magazines of more than ten rounds, holding that the ban violated the Second Amendment.

It was a major legal battle, with the Democrat attorneys general of no less than seventeen states weighing in on California’s side in support of the ban. The NRA, the National Shooting Sports Federation, and a host of local gun groups argued against the ban.

The decision was not unanimous; it was a 2-1 vote. But for court-watchers, it was an astonishing thing to see it come from the Ninth Circuit. Six other circuits, specifically the First, Second, Third, Fourth, Seventh, and D.C. Circuits, had previously sustained large-capacity magazine (LCM) bans against Second Amendment challenges.

The two judges in the majority of the Ninth Circuit panel were Judges Kenneth Lee (a Trump appointee) and Consuelo Callahan (a George W. Bush appointee). The dissent was written by Judge Barbara Lynn, a district judge from the Northern District of Texas (appointed by Clinton), who was sitting on the Ninth Circuit panel by designation. In decisions involving politicized issues like gun control, the name of the president who appointed a judge often speaks volumes.

As has been noted of late, the once left-leaning Ninth Circuit has changed a great deal during President Trump’s first term in office. President Trump has appointed no less than ten of the court’s 29 active-status judges. Combined with the three active-status appointees of George W. Bush, they are approaching the 50% mark. If President Trump wins a second term and gets to fill two more vacancies, the majority of Ninth Circuit judges will be Republican appointees. Already, in any given cases, there’s a decent chance that two of those thirteen Republican-appointed judges will land on the same randomly-selected panel. Duncan v. Becerra illustrates that fact perfectly.

The decision also sets up future battles in the U.S. Supreme Court. There is now, finally, a circuit-split on the issue—where there is a disagreement among the circuits on the same legal question. Under such circumstances, it is much more likely that the Supreme Court will take the case when it is offered.

When and if the case goes to the Supreme Court, one can only hope that the high court echoes the Ninth Circuit majority opinion written by Judge Lee.

Judge Lee’s opinion makes clear that the Second Amendment protects the magazine of semi-automatic firearms, as well as the firearms themselves. Importantly, the opinion holds that such restrictions must be subjected to “strict scrutiny” in the courts—the highest level of scrutiny. Under that standard, a law can only be sustained if the government has a “compelling state interest” and if the law is “narrowly tailored” to advance that interest. That is the same standard that applies to most other rights found in the Bill of Rights.

Judge Lee also destroys the progressive notion that law-abiding citizens don’t need more than ten rounds to defend themselves: “[I]t does not take a wild imagination to conclude that citizens may need LCMs to defend hearth and home. … In [rural] places, the closest law enforcement may be far, far away — and it may take substantial time for the county sheriff to respond. And it is no guarantee that the things that go bump in the night come alone; indeed, burglars often ply their trade in groups recognizing strength in numbers. … And in incidents of mass chaos and unrest, law enforcement simply may be unable to protect the people, leaving them solely responsible for their own safety in a seemingly Hobbesian world.”

Indeed. Let’s hope that at least five justices of the Supreme Court analyze the matter in similarly sober terms when the case gets there.

Kris W. Kobach was a professor of constitutional law during 1996-2011 at the University of Missouri-KC. He served as counsel to U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft during 2001-2003, and he served as the Secretary of State of Kansas during 2011-2019. He is currently General Counsel of We Build the Wall

Source link

Articles You May Like

Outdoors in RI: (Pneumonia edition) The Hunt. 2A active. Vote Gundies. Pearl Harbor – Jeff Gross
NRA and Sportsman’s Alliance of Maine should support gun licensing
23 GOP State Attorneys General Warn Firms to Stop Backing Efforts to ‘De-Bank’ Conservatives
Kentucky lawmakers should heed lesson from Louisville mass shooting
Maryland attorney general seeks court review after ruling strikes down handgun licensing law


  1. 223134 925241When I initially commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a remark is added I get four emails with exactly the same comment. Is there any manner you possibly can take away me from that service? Thanks! 625629

  2. 422346 136541You created some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the concern and located most individuals will go along with with your web site. 136929

  3. 85528 382439Amazing beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your site, how could i subscribe for a blog internet site? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been just a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear thought 4127

  4. анапа новый год 2022 санаторий полтава крым саки отзывы
    отель парус ростов на дону гостевой дом никос адлер курортное отели
    санатории в крыму с бассейном петровка 17 отель гостиница полесье

  5. шингари сукко официальный мрия резорт официальный сайт цены
    лазурный берег сочи хостел в симферополе монплезир казань гостиница
    отдых с лечением в россии реабокс сухая углекислая ванна цена процедуры дивноморское все включено

  6. отзывы санаторий дюльбер ялта 2021 гостиницы железноводска цены
    литфонд аукцион отдых в крыму в ноябре 2021 петр отель евпатория официальный сайт
    отель кемпински геленджик отзывы гостиница фрегат судак санаторий нарат официальный сайт

  7. гостиница выборга кисловодск эльбрус
    отдых в сочи 2020 все включено крым курорт курортные места абхазии
    парк отель солнечный промокод крытый бассейн в адлере для платного посещения ессентуки санаторий казахстан цены

  8. отель амран гагра абхазия цены 2021 орбита сочи
    гостиница роялта алупка русь ессентуки отзывы 2021 санаторий дюльбер в крыму
    кореновская 57 1 самый лучший отель в анапе отдых в подмосковье на 5 дней

  9. санаторий хазино отзывы отдых с детьми ру
    пансионат буран ржд анапа санаторий дилуч отзывы гавань надежды в жуковском
    тур на сочи санаторий русь геленджик отзывы анапа шведский стол

  10. санаторий бай официальный сайт гостиницы новокузнецка дешевые
    база отдыха севастополь мо санаторий минобороны евпатория база отдыха на алтае цены
    лечение псориаза в россии azimut hotel sochi 4 династия санкт петербург отзывы

  11. отель парк инн в казани оленевка крым отели с бассейном
    гостиница приморский парк аурелия севастополь отели с завтраком
    курорт юбилейный башкирия официальный сайт санатории для лечения почек курорт горячинск стоимость путевки на 7 дней

  12. гостиницы в сочи цена гостиница амстердам
    отель сити плаза геленджик официальный сайт spa звездный сочи хостел сода арзамас
    ялта круглый год официальный сайт цены где лечат нейропатию нижних конечностей пансионаты адлера с собственным пляжем

  13. витязево пансионаты санаторий ян татарстан
    ессентуки отель источник все для отдыха марриотт воронеж
    комплекс дагомыс сочи официальный сайт заказать путевку на море лечебный санаторий в подмосковье для пенсионеров

  14. город курорт адлер отель оркестра горизонт геленджик официальный сайт
    voda акваклуб спб симеиз отзывы отдыхающих 2021 база отдыха селигерское заплавье отзывы
    озеро банное башкирия цены 2021 гостевой дом азур нугуш отель бристоль ялта акция для крымчан 2021

  15. геленджик отель alean family resort spa biarritz кондопога гостиницы
    пансионаты в алуште ессентуки курорты отели на море
    пансионат дубна крым база отдыха высокий берег астрахань санаторий солнечный пятигорск

  16. южное крым санаторий надежда в анапе отзывы
    санаторий удельная московская область официальный сайт отель форсаж таганрог санаторий ставрополь тольятти цены на 2021 год
    отель солнечный в подмосковье все включено фото санаторно курортное лечение после инсульта санаторий виктория в пушкинском районе московской области

  17. сан горького кисловодск пансионаты тверской области
    гостиница алгоритм казань бургас сочи фото ростов на дону гостиницы 5 звезд
    отель дубрава самара дом в абхазии купить здравницы кисловодска цены

  18. дол чайка отзывы гостиница в пензе
    турбаза севастополь мо рф официальный сайт хостел столица уфа отель ривьера абхазия
    чагда беловодье белокуриха улица академика мясникова 4 гостиница кириши

  19. база алания архыз отель бридж сочи
    отель знаменская санкт петербург официальный сайт горный алтай отели на берегу анапа маяк
    рэдиссон сас сочи гостиница альбатрос пермь отель в азове

  20. 818629 653145Hey there. I want to to inquire somethingis this a wordpress weblog as we are thinking about shifting over to WP. Also did you make this theme on your personal? Thanks. 782226

  21. 776254 286146I enjoy the look of your site. I recently built mine and I was looking for some ideas for my internet site and you gave me a few. May possibly I ask you whether you developed the site by youself? 933503

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *