The last president to appoint three justices in his first term was Richard M. Nixon, but his picks included Justice Harry Blackmun, the author of Roe v. Wade who became one of the most liberal justices on the court. Trump’s picks, by contrast, have been outstanding. With his appointment of Neil M. Gorsuch to replace Antonin Scalia, Trump saved the court’s conservative majority. With his appointment of Brett M. Kavanaugh to replace Anthony M. Kennedy — a swing vote — he inched the court to the right. And now by appointing Barrett to replace Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the court’s liberal icon, Trump has secured a decisive 6-to-3 conservative majority. This will affect the court’s jurisprudence for a generation, with far-reaching consequences for life, religious liberty, free speech, Second Amendment rights, the separation of powers and limited government.
Imagine how different the court would look today if Hillary Clinton had won the 2016 election. She probably would have nominated a judicial activist to replace Scalia, creating a 5-to-4 liberal majority. She would have replaced Ginsburg with another liberal, securing that seat for decades. She might have had a third pick if Justice Stephen G. Breyer made the same decision as Kennedy and retired when a president he trusted was in office. The damage done by the activist liberal court Clinton ushered in would have been breathtaking.
Simply stopping this is an accomplishment. But Trump has made better judicial choices than any modern Republican president. Of Ronald Reagan’s three appointees (Sandra Day O’Connor, Scalia and Kennedy), only Scalia was a consistent conservative. George H.W. Bush appointed one solid conservative (Clarence Thomas) and one solid liberal (David H. Souter). George W. Bush picked one reliable conservative (Samuel A. Alito Jr.) and one wavering justice (John G. Roberts Jr.). By contrast, the four liberal justices appointed over the past quarter century — Ginsburg, Breyer, Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor — almost never defect on close 5-to-4 cases. So, Democrats have a perfect record on recent Supreme Court appointments, while Republicans were not even batting .500 — until Trump came along.
Perhaps Trump’s greatest accomplishment will be neutralizing the influence of Roberts. After promising to be an impartial umpire, Roberts has taken the field and legislated from the bench in a string of cases — voting with the court’s liberals to rewrite Obamacare, preserve the Deferred Action on Childhood Arrivals program, block a citizenship question on the census, strike down state laws that required admitting privileges for doctors who perform abortions and allow the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to rewrite the state’s election laws. And those are just his defections on cases the court took up. According to CNN, “Roberts also sent enough signals during internal deliberations on firearms restrictions, sources said, to convince fellow conservatives he would not provide a critical fifth vote anytime soon to overturn gun control regulations. As a result, the justices in June denied several petitions regarding Second Amendment rights.”
Thanks to Trump, Roberts is no longer the swing vote. If Barrett agrees with the legal reasoning of her conservative colleagues, they have the five votes they need without him.
Trump’s appointment of Barrett also complicates Democrats’ plans to reverse this progress via court-packing if they win back the White House and the Senate next week. Before her appointment, Democrats would have had to expand the court by two justices to flip the 5-to-4 conservative majority into a 6-to-5 liberal majority. But now with Barrett on the court, they would have to add four justices in order to achieve a 7-to-6 liberal majority. Given that Americans support Barrett’s confirmation 51 to 28 percent, oppose court-packing 58 to 31 percent and approve of the high court’s performance 53 to 47 percent, for Democrats to add any new seats — much less the four needed to flip the court — would be widely seen as a raw power grab.
That doesn’t mean they won’t try. Voters have a chance to stop them by preserving a Republican majority in the Senate. If history is our guide, Trump may have more Supreme Court appointments in a second term — and with them the opportunity to further preserve or even expand the court’s conservative majority. As for the 26 percent of Trump voters who backed him because of the Supreme Court, their decision has produced a court that will protect our freedoms for decades to come. Any other flaws in the Trump presidency pale by comparison.
350318 340139As soon as I discovered this web web site I went on reddit to share some with the love with them. 882
952819 86908Cpr KIts very wonderful read you know alot about this topic i see! 527125
478549 423379Great paintings! This really is the kind of info that need to be shared around the internet. Disgrace on Google for now not positioning this publish upper! Come on over and speak over with my website . Thanks =) 253220
706675 274847But wanna say that this really is very valuable , Thanks for taking your time to write this. 527217
201734 808616Real informative and wonderful anatomical structure of subject material , now thats user pleasant (:. 146595
811745 143649appreciate the effort you put into obtaining us this details. Was searching on google and identified your post randomly. 934378
367318 511478Thanks for the post. I like your writing style – Im trying to start a weblog myself, I believe I may well read thru all your posts for some suggestions! Thanks once far more. 104878
439501 182716I conceive this internet web site has got some quite excellent information for everyone : D. 886705
255273 959849appreciate the effort you put into finding us this data 377542
32811 940202certainly like your web site however you have to take a look at the spelling on several of your posts. 379308
554020 430902I like this website quite considerably so significantly superb info . 482767
973040 563158This site is typically a walk-through you discover the info it suited you about it and didnt know who require to. Glimpse here, and youll definitely discover it. 934857
390244 934749I genuinely enjoyed this. It was extremely educational and helpful. I will return to examine on upcoming posts 286558
477082 768594 very good post, i certainly enjoy this site, maintain on it 44850
791543 881029You ought to take part in a contest for among the most effective blogs on the internet. I will suggest this web web site! 67787
146030 737666Watch the strategies presented continue reading to discover and just listen how to carry out this incredible like you organize your company at the moment. educational 178070
339363 158321This really is a excellent topic to speak about. Sometimes I fav stuff like this on Redit. This post probably wont do effectively with that crowd. I will likely be positive to submit something else though. 871413