Joe Biden knows he needs to appear to be doing something about crime.
Murder rates around the country rose precipitously in 2020, and in many cities the increases have continued into 2021. But the president has few levers to affect crime quickly, and faces political hazards in every direction. Biden has championed police reform, and many progressive Democrats have pushed for sharp reductions in police budgets.
The result was an unsatisfying announcement yesterday, delivered by a meandering Biden and Attorney General Merrick Garland, about new federal efforts to fight gun violence.
The public is alarmed. While crime remains lower than it was at its 1990s peak, a recent poll conducted by Leger in collaboration with The Atlantic finds that six in 10 Americans view crime in the country as a major issue. The problem, for Biden, is that there’s simply not much the federal government can do: The fastest initiatives seem unlikely to have much effect, while others have more potential but are unlikely to come to fruition soon. Law enforcement in the United States is largely conducted on the local and state levels, with a limited federal role. Federal efforts at crime fighting can have unintended consequences, as the huge increase in incarceration that followed the 1994 crime bill demonstrated.
One thing Washington does effectively is shovel money at a problem, a brute-force way to fight, for example, a pandemic-induced economic downturn. Crime doesn’t necessarily work the same way. What drives crime—both up, as is the case now, and down, as occured from the ’90s until recently—is not well understood. Money can be used to, for example, hire more police officers, but training cops takes time, and besides, many departments are already struggling to fill open, funded positions, according to a survey from the Police Executive Research Forum.
[Derek Thompson: Why America’s great crime decline is over]
Writing checks to hire cops might be politically untenable for Biden. Although the president pointedly distanced himself from Democrats who have called for defunding the police, a huge increase in federal funding to departments would likely spark an insurrection on his left flank, at a moment when the president is already struggling to hold together his fragile coalition on voting rights and infrastructure—not to mention trying to nurture a bipartisan police-reform bill.
Biden focused his efforts on gun violence instead. On Tuesday, the Justice Department announced the creation of new gun-trafficking strike forces in five major cities, with the goal of stemming the illegal flow of guns.
“With these strike forces, local and federal law enforcement and prosecutors are going to be able to better coordinate the prosecution of illegal gun trafficking across city and state lines, so illegal guns sold from the back door of a gun shop in Virginia don’t end up at a murder scene in Baltimore,” Biden said yesterday.
This makes political sense: Most Democrats agree on at least modest increases in gun control, and large portions of the population support measures such as universal background checks. Stricter enforcement against illegal gun trafficking is simple enough, because it relies on existing laws. Moreover, contra the familiar NRA slogan, guns do kill people; firearms consistently account for a large majority of murders in the United States, and there’s evidence of a big recent jump in the number of guns that Americans own. Other categories of crime have not increased the way murders have over the past year.
Whether this focus on firearms will really affect crime is a different question. Criminologists don’t agree on the specific causes and mechanisms of the recent increase in murders, which coincided with the coronavirus pandemic and especially with protests against police violence last summer. Fighting the root causes requires understanding what they are, but in the meantime, Biden’s focus on gun trafficking might have limited effect.
“What it’s doing is trying to address the supply, and it’s not doing a thing about the demand,” Jerry Ratcliffe, a criminal-justice professor at Temple University, told me. “We have a vicious cycle. Guns on the street are fueling shootings, and more shootings are fueling more guns on the street.”
[Read: What caused the great crime decline in the U.S.?]
The federal government can only go after guns that are being sold illegally. But most guns are purchased and owned legally. Biden would surely be happy to sign more sweeping gun controls, but Republicans in Congress continue to block any new legislation, and previous Democratic presidents have already tried many of the most promising executive actions.
The most intriguing element of Biden’s announcement is a push for community violence-intervention (CVI) programs. While there are a range of designs for these programs, some of them have shown impressive efficacy in reducing gun violence. Mark Obbie wrote about the promising results of such programs in stopping shootings in The Atlantic in 2019.
Thomas Abt, a senior fellow at the Council on Criminal Justice and a former Justice Department official, has championed such efforts, and told me he was cautiously optimistic about the Biden initiatives.
Yesterday’s announcement “features much-needed federal resources for law enforcement, community-based service providers, the hiring of returning citizens, and more,” he said. “Partnership across sectors and constituencies will continue to be critical in the fight against gun violence.”
Making CVI programs work requires time, money, and the right partners. The White House has told local governments that they can use money from the American Rescue Plan, the stimulus bill passed in March, for CVI programs. Biden has also asked Congress to allocate $5 billion for these programs. But even if Congress agreed, that money wouldn’t be available in time to mitigate the annual summer surge in violence.
Biden has been careful not to overpromise, warning, “There is no one answer that fits everything.” That’s certainly the case, but it’s unlikely to absolve the Biden administration in the public’s mind, during what may be a very violent summer ahead.
This article was originally published in The Atlantic. Sign up for their newsletter.
431924 72039It is actually a cool and valuable piece of information. Im glad that you simply shared this beneficial data with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing. 981495
740545 929119We dont trust this wonderful submit. Nevertheless, I saw it gazed for Digg along with Ive determined you can be appropriate so i ended up being imagining within the completely wrong way. Persist with writing top quality stuff along these lines. 527013
734955 80087Hello. Neat post. There is an problem with your site in firefox, and you may want to test this The browser could be the market chief and a big part of other men and women will miss your wonderful writing because of this problem. 858147
153461 61831Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn something like this before. So nice to search out any person with some unique thoughts on this topic. realy thank you for starting this up. this internet website is 1 thing thats needed on the net, someone with a bit of originality. helpful job for bringing something new towards the internet! 30148
987205 497685There is noticeably plenty of money to comprehend this. I assume you made certain good points in capabilities also. 325607
810203 275577Great information many thanks sharing and reaching us your subscriber list. 824582
912819 381260This web site is generally a walk-through its the information you wished about this and didnt know who ought to. Glimpse here, and you will undoubtedly discover it. 981922
93138 748262This web web site is my inspiration , truly superb layout and perfect subject matter. 276169
540211 788819You produced some decent points there. I looked on-line for any dilemma and located most individuals will go in conjunction with together with your website. 582653
171811 997273Some truly nice and utilitarian details on this internet website , likewise I think the style and style holds wonderful attributes. 926614
258185 606927Nice read. I just passed this onto a buddy who was performing some research on that. He just bought me lunch since I located it for him! Thus let me rephrase: Thanx for lunch! 258650
376867 993659Aw, this became an extremely good post. In thought I would like to devote writing such as this moreover – taking time and actual effort to make a extremely very good article but exactly what do I say I procrastinate alot and by no means find a method to get something completed. 13051
416125 946487Outstanding post, I feel weblog owners need to larn a great deal from this web site its rattling user friendly . 712174
940879 357685I see something actually special in this internet web site . 508857
935950 327825Yeah bookmaking this wasnt a risky determination outstanding post! . 608995
184438 730949I dont usually comment but I gotta state thanks for the post on this wonderful 1 : D. 902021