NRA affiliate picks up ally in Supreme Court gun case: Defense attorneys

Gun News


play

A New York gun-rights case that could potentially reshape concealed-carry laws in America has pulled together a pair of unlikely allies: A chapter of the National Rifle Association, and a group of defense attorneys who say it’s a racial-justice issue.  

banner

The New York State Rifle & Pistol Association is a plaintiff in the Rensselaer County-based case challenging a state law that limits gun-carrying outside the home without a license. 

The case, which has made its way to the U.S. Supreme Court, has a chance to set a national precedent.

On July 22, Black Attorneys of Legal Aid, Bronx Defenders and public defenders spread across the state filed an amicus brief in support of the challenge, claiming it unfairly affects their clients, most of whom are poor and Black or Latino.

Although New York allows for permits to carry concealed guns with a license, the state law makes it virtually impossible for the ordinary law-abiding citizen to obtain one, both the lawyer and gun-rights groups argue.

The lawyer group — which included public defenders offices in Monroe, Ontario, Wayne and Oneida counties, among others — said the law renders the Second Amendment “legal fiction” for their clients.

The group also says that the requirement falls in line with a history of keeping guns out the hands of racial and ethnic minorities.

The state law mandating a license to carry a pistol outside their homes requires license-seekers to show “proper cause,” or a special need for requiring the gun outside their home.

Each year, the public defender group said they needlessly represent too many indigent Black and Latino clients in gun-possession cases — all because of New York’s gun-licensing requirement.  

“New York violates our clients’ rights to keep and bear arms by arresting, jailing, and prosecuting them for possessing a firearm — anywhere — unless they have applied to and survived the state’s expensive and onerous discretionary licensing process,” the brief argued.

Brief comes amid push for tougher gun laws

The group’s stance comes amid a progressive push for more stringent gun laws after an uptick in shootings across the country. 

President Joe Biden, who recently launched a new crime-prevention strategy, called gun violence a “public health epidemic” and a “national embarrassment.”

Moreover, public officials in New York lambasted the case, expressing concerns about public safety.

Yet, the group of public defenders said their “clients’ conduct would not be a crime in states that already properly recognize the Second Amendment.” By keeping the statute in place, many people of color become entrenched in the criminal-justice system because they don’t have the correct licensing, the brief claims.

“We routinely see people charged with a violent felony for simply possessing a firearm outside of the home, a crime only because they had not gotten a license beforehand,” the brief argued. 

In April, the Supreme Court decided to take up the case after more than a decade since handling a gun-rights case – and it is likely to have major implications for other states such as New Jersey and Hawaii that have similar requirements.  

MOREBiden targets illegal gun sales, rogue dealers in strategy to combat rising crime

GUNS IN AMERICA: Nearly 40 million guns were purchased legally in 2020 and another 4.1 million bought in January

Two Rensselaer County men and the state Rifle & Pistol Association filed the lawsuit. The pair had been denied a permit because they each failed to show “proper cause” to carry a firearm in public for self-defense.

The lawsuit later said it’s nearly impossible for regular people to get the right licensing. In turn, the consequences of making the process so onerous have led to racially disparate arrests in New York, the legal group argued in the brief. 

Black people made up 18% of the state’s population last year but they account for 78% of the state’s felony gun cases, according to pretrial release data cited in the public defenders’ brief. Non-Latino white people conversely accounted for 7% of the prosecutions while making up 70% of the population.

Public officials vow to fight case

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and others have vowed to fight the case, saying in April that the NRA-backed suit was a threat to public safety.

“The streets of New York are not the O.K. Corral, and the NRA’s dream of a society where everyone is terrified of each other and armed to the teeth is abhorrent to our values,” Cuomo said in a statement.

New York City Police Commissioner Dermot Shea told Bloomberg News that adding more guns to “our” streets is not the answer to reducing violence. Instead, he said in the statement, the NYPD should continue to regulate the conditions to legally carry a loaded firearm on their streets.

The public defenders’ group is holding steadfast in their concerns even as the nation sees an uptick in gun violence. The public defenders’ group called the law “brutal” to their clients, including some who might have gotten a gun because of violence in their communities.

The Supreme Court is expected to take up the case in its next term, which starts in October.

Tiffany Cusaac-Smith covers race and justice for the USA TODAY Network of New York. Click here for her latest stories. Follow her on Twitter @T_Cusaac





Source link

Articles You May Like

The wheel of gun violence keeps on rolling
Second Amendment Activists, Congressmen, See More at Stake Than Braces
As trauma from gun violence builds, survivors campaign for change
Training could break stalemate on guns
ILA | New Mexico: Radical Gun Restrictions on Deck in Committee Next Week: Magazine Limits, Waiting Periods, Semi-Auto, Suppressor & NFA Bans

24 Comments

  1. 356369 890563An intriguing discussion is worth comment. I believe which you really should write a lot more on this topic, it may well not be a taboo topic but normally people are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers 653793

  2. 709292 900630I like what you guys are up also. Such intelligent function and reporting! Maintain up the superb works guys Ive incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I believe itll improve the value of my site . 564280

  3. ейск мини гостиницы рядом с морем санаторий крепость официальный сайт
    дельфин в адлере вытегра отель автомобилист сочи официальный
    броско отель москва гостиница флогистон санкт петербург сукко краснодарский край отдых

  4. в абхазию на новый год 2022 атрий симеиз официальный сайт
    сан 30 лет победы железноводск гостиница евразия батайск дол чайка евпатория
    загородный отдых москва что такое бювет в санатории озеро сновидений пансионат

  5. отель порто маре в крыму радоновые ванны в сочи
    санаторий орбита 2 солнечногорский hotel сочи прометей небуг
    санаторий саки официальный сайт цены гостиницы геленджика с бассейном партенит отдых 2021

  6. раннее бронирование отель арктика салехард
    пансионат горный горячий ключ санаторий азнакаево официальный сайт отель каисса адлер официальный сайт цены
    крым г саки пансионаты в подмосковье недорого отдых в крыму с детьми частный сектор

  7. хуторок джемете спа отель гагра абхазия
    санаторий для диабетиков краснодарский край санаторий транспортник туапсе официальный сайт база отдыха адлер цены на 2021
    база отдыха родное севастополь официальный сайт где лучше отдохнуть в минеральных водах красная талка геленджик медицинский центр

  8. фандорин отель кабардинка официальный сайт западное побережье крыма отдых с детьми
    гостиница оазис в адлере холидей инн дмитровское шоссе хайат сочи отель официальный
    загорские дали санаторий отзывы довиль анапа фото гостиница царская крымск

  9. санатории феодосии цены mria крым
    соляная пещера в абхазии анапа гинекология гостиницы серова свердловской области
    сова гостиница нижний новгород вулкан в анапе санаторий лаба в краснодарском крае цены

  10. конгресс отель ареал официальный сайт купавна отдых в оленевке
    усадьба фэмили краснодар пятигорск база отдыха клиника в карелии кивач
    холидей инн садовая 62 солнечный отель и спа феодосия хостел

  11. head hostel hotel санкт петербург отдых в крыму 2021 санатории
    путевки в белокуриха санатории цены 2021 авиастар гостиница ульяновск официальный сайт санатории кисловодска
    отдых в мацесте 2021 цены пансионат челюскинцев гагра абхазия официальный санаторий ривьера сочи официальный сайт

  12. дом отдыха бетта для военнослужащих гостиницы в городе мценск
    гостиница в калуге зимний отдых отель горки нижний новгород официальный
    санаторий ломоносов пансионат южный берег отель сокол домбай официальный сайт

  13. отель день и ночь омск все санатории белокурихи
    ресторан сан ремо сочи гостиница колос каневская репино спа отзывы
    истра санаторий работников прокуратуры рф официальный сайт sea galaxy отель сочи гостиницы переславля залесского цены

  14. санаторий пушкино гурзуф официальный сайт бархатный сезон отель
    узбекистан кисловодск официальный сайт ibis бахрушина официальный сайт путевки в кисловодск цены на 2021
    гостевой дом альяна бассейн для детей дцп санаторий родина евпатория

  15. князь владимир гостиница отели в феодосии крым
    отель вернисаж великий новгород сортавала отели с бассейном маслянино санаторий для пенсионеров цены
    достоевский отель санкт петербург официальный сайт крым партенит курорты белоруссии с лечением и стоимость 2021

  16. отели краснодар отель в евпатории с бассейном
    туры в сочи купить бетта базы отдыха парк отель сочи официальный
    отель графский москва санатории на выходные евпатория пансионаты

  17. анапа поселок витязево отели отель николь пермь
    отель фэмили витязево михайловская батарея севастополь официальный сайт мартон пашковский краснодар
    старица официальный сайт домина новосибирск отель брайтон парк алушта

  18. 737420 114654Can I just now say that of a relief to locate somebody who truly knows what theyre speaking about online. You actually know how to bring a difficulty to light and work out it crucial. The diet need to have to see this and appreciate this side on the story. I cant believe youre no a lot more popular since you definitely possess the gift. 340595

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *