[ad_1]
Circuit Judge Chip Welch today refused to dismiss a taxpayers’ lawsuit challenging Attorney General Leslie Rutledge’s spending of public money on ads that promote her image and on out-of-state lawsuits.
Rutledge contends she’s immune from lawsuits and subject only to voters and in some spending decisions, the General Assembly.
The lawsuit alleges an illegal expenditure of tax money, an argument that can surmount a defense of immunity from lawsuits for public officials under the Arkansas Constitution.
Rutledge also argued those suing her didn’t have standing. Welch said taxpayers had standing. He wrote:
Defendant argues that taxpayers have no standing to contest her expenditures of funds. This Court disagrees. The Court FINDS Plaintiffs have SUFFICIENTLY PLEADED STANDING through alleging the use of public, state and taxpayer funds; some established by the legislature, some from monies collected by the Attorney General’s offtce through settlements, and money judgments collected in favor of the State, in cases wherein the State was a party,but all of which involve the use of staff, and resources of the Attorney General of Arkansas, as funded by taxpayers
As for immunity, Welch wrote:
The Court FINDS that facts alleged in the Amended Complaint, viewed in the light most favorable to Plaintiffs, as required under the Rule, support the determination 1) that the past and pending actions of the Attorney General are ultra vires or without the authority of law, and (2) that the Attomey General is about to (and continuing to) act in bad faith, arbitrarily, capriciously, and in a wantonly injurious manner, which would justify injunctive and declaratory relief. Accordingly, the Motion to Dismiss on grounds of Sovereign Immunity is DENIED.
2. Plaintiff has sufficiently alleged “Acts in bad faith, arbitrarily, capriciously pursued, in a wantonly injurious manner”, which would further justify overcoming the defense of Qualified Immunity. See factual allegations discussed elsewhere in this order. For example, Plaintiffs cite, among other acts, Defendant’s invocation of the imprimatur of the State of Arkansas in defense of the National Rifle Association in New York, and the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Texas. This is an exercise of power under the ‘color of law’, where the Attorney General is alleged to have intentionally acted in her capacity as a State actor for her own gain. The Court also FINDS that facts alleged in the Amended Complaint, viewed in the light most favorable to Plaintiffs, overcome Qualified Immunity at this stage. The Motion to Dismiss on Qualified Immunity Grounds is DENIED.
The plaintiffs have argued that Rutledge’s wide-ranging legal activities, such as defending the NRA, are meant to enhance her politically. She is a candidate for governor next year. She recently resumed using her voice and image in public service announcements, a practice she’d stopped last year after criticism arose to some $2 million spending on ads featuring her. Her latest ads, about $1 million worth, urge people to get vaccinated.
Welch elaborated on the argument that Rutledge had improperly spent state money on lawsuits.
The Motion to Dismiss the Complaint’s prayer for relief for an “illegal exaction” as to Defendant’s involvement in filing amicus briefs concerning the 2020 election, and as to Defendant’s “consumer” TV Commercials is a close question as to the application of Sovereign Immunity. Defendant’s action in these discrete cases concemed matters of arguable public interest (to Arkansans). However, the discrete acts, as distinguished from others (See: the NRA Bankruptcy, supra), are of evidentiary value when viewed in the light of the totality of additional specific actions alleged elsewhere in the Amended Complaint. A pattern or course of conduct, (See, inter a/ia: discussion regarding NRA Bankruptcy, supra) of using the public persona of the Attomey General as an adjunct to a gubernatorial campaign (again, considering, as the Court must, ‘well-pleaded facts’) emerges supporting the conclusion that the Motion to Dismiss should fail at this stage. For example, Plaintiffs also question Defendant’s invocation of the imprimatur of the State of Arkansas acting in defense of the National Rifle Association in New York, and the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Texas. This is a more troubling exercise of power under the ‘color of law’, where the Attorney General allegedly acted in her capacity as a State actor for the benefit of a citizen and “person” , in a private bankruptcy, in a foreign state, allegedly for political gain.
Hard case. Perhaps hard to win under the law. But let’s be real. Rutledge has spent millions in public money to enhance her chances of being elected governor. And given the opportunity, her Republican opponent, Sarah Huckabee Sanders, would likely do the same.
The lawsuit now lingers to a degree in the coming election campaign. The primary is in March. No trial date has been set. I’m seeking comments from lawyers and thoughts on whether there’s a chance for Rutledge to appeal this ruling ahead of trial.
UPDATE: A statement on behalf of Rutledge:
The opinion issued by the trial court fails to appropriately consider the actual legal responsibilities Attorney General Leslie Rutledge has to educate and advocate on behalf of Arkansas consumers. The Attorney General plans to immediately appeal this erroneous decision.”
[ad_2]
Source link
289416 714118wonderful points altogether, you just gained a brand new reader. 91895
666351 840397Safest the world toasts are created to captivate and also faithfulness to your wedding couple. Beginner sound system watching high decibel locations would be wise to always remember some sort of vital secret created by presentation, which is your auto. finest man speeches funny 184922
910977 170137I like this blog its a master peace ! Glad I observed this on google . 331624
[url=https://stromectolgf.online/#]cost of ivermectin pill[/url] stromectol without prescription
992762 570490whoah this blog is magnificent i love reading your posts. Keep up the excellent work! You know, lots of men and women are searching around for this info, you could support them greatly. 217322
201994 243182There is noticeably a whole lot to realize about this. I suppose you produced certain nice points in features also. 621386
583980 409546I adore your wp style, wherever did you download it by means of? 152020
867436 347551Awesome inkling Grace! ego was luxurious youd bring about this about your biz bump into upstanding lineage. We reason you! 240088
333299 784177There a couple of interesting points over time here but I dont know if I see them all center to heart. There exists some validity but Let me take hold opinion until I appear into it further. Really excellent post , thanks and now we want a lot more! Included with FeedBurner at exactly the same time 310329
954987 272920I adore your writing style truly enjoying this web website . 506805
138720 641524 You created some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the concern and discovered most individuals will go along with together with your internet site. 781255
718081 50670very good day, your internet internet site is inexpensive. I do numerous thanks for succeed 692864
608280 485868I real pleased to uncover this web site on bing, just what I was seeking for : D too saved to bookmarks . 56427
36662 879040I want going to comment as this posts a bit old now, but just wanted to say thanks. 527884
936596 286313Im glad to become a visitor in this pure internet site, regards for this rare info! 693393
539313 954928You produced some decent points there. I looked on-line for any difficulty and identified most individuals will go in conjunction with with your internet site. 195690
292483 130322Lastly, got what I was looking for!! Ive truly enjoying every small bit of this. Ecstatic I stumbled into this post! and also Ive bookmarked to appear at unique information for your weblog post. 543982
50741 143382I actually appreciate your piece of work, Great post. 171440
Helo there I am so glad I found yoir site, I realy found
you bby mistake, while I wwas reserching onn Diggg
for something else, Anyhjow I amm here now and would jusdt like tto saay thanks a lot foor a tremeendous ost andd a all round thrilling bblog (I alpso love tthe theme/design), I don’t havee tine
too look ovdr it alll at thee inute but I have saved it annd lso added iin your RSS feeds, soo when I hav time
I will bbe back too reqd much more, Please do keep upp the siperb jo.
326955 48378I like this internet weblog extremely considerably so significantly superb information . 949198
267052 298376Currently it seems like BlogEngine will be the very best blogging platform out there right now. (from what Ive read) Is that what youre utilizing on your blog? 858180
420743 138283I genuinely enjoy the theme on your web site, I run a internet website , and i would adore to use this theme. Is it a no cost style, or is it custom? 199885
927667 578493When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now every time a remark is added I get four emails with exactly the same comment. Is there any approach youll be able to remove me from that service? Thanks! 825783
489469 356424There some intriguing points over time here but I dont know if I see them all center to heart. There exists some validity but Let me take hold opinion until I appear into it further. Very good post , thanks and now we want far more! Included with FeedBurner at the same time 783773
506812 723806So, is this just for men, just for females, or is it for both sexes If it s not, then do ladies require to do anything different to put on muscle 775655